Table 2: Grain yields of non-wheat crops.

 

 

 

2002

 

1996-2002 Avg

 

 

Crop

 

Yield

Oil

 

Yield

Oil

 

 

 

 

lb/a

%

 

lb/a

%

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Grain Lentil

 

911

--

 

984

--

 

 

Field Pea

 

1243

--

 

1386

--

 

 

Safflower

 

898

33.6

 

591

32.1

 

             

 

Applying insufficient N to continuous wheat reduced wheat yield this year and in four of the previous six years. Applying excessive N to wheat following green manure did not increase wheat yield this year or any of the eighteen cases (i.e., three legume species × six years) during the previous six years. The finding that insufficient N usually reduced yield and that excess N seldom increased yield supports the validity of fertilizer recommendations based on soil testing.

 

Table 3: HRSW performance in the WREC Annual Legume Study

 

N

2002

 

1996-2002 Average

Previous Crop

Treatment

N

Yield

Protein

 

Yield

Protein

 

 

lb/a

bu/a

%

 

bu/a

%

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wheat

Recommended

60

36.3

15.1

 

30.4

15.2

Wheat

Insufficient

0

19.1

11.9

 

21.6

12.3

Fallow

Recommended

60

37.2

17.0

 

36.9

15.7

Safflower

Recommended

30

32.6

16.1

 

27.4

16.1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Forage Lentil

Recommended

0

36.2

16.0

 

29.3

16.2

Green Manure [F.L.]

Recommended

0

34.9

17.1

 

36.7

15.7

Green Manure [F.L.]

Excessive

60

34.2

17.9

 

37.0

16.4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Grain Lentil

Recommended

0

32.3

16.1

 

29.1

16.4

Green Manure [G.L.]

Recommended

0

38.7

16.9

 

37.4

15.2

Green Manure [G.L.]

Excessive

60

37.9

17.8

 

37.1

16.4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Field Pea

Recommended

0

33.6

15.7

 

31.8

15.7

Green Manure [F.P.]

Recommended

0

33.7

16.8

 

36.6

15.6

Green Manure [F.P.]

Excessive

60

34.5

18.0

 

37.6

16.3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Average

 

 

33.9

16.3

 

33.0

15.6

LSD (5%)

 

 

6.6

0.6

 

    --

    --

Wheat protein content was generally greater (9 of 13 cases) this year than the corresponding 7-year average (Table 3). Protein content of the continuous wheat with insufficient N was lower than any other treatment. 

Applying insufficient N to continuous wheat reduced wheat grain protein this year and in five of the six previous years. Applying excessive N to wheat following green manure increased wheat grain protein in all three cases (i.e., three legume species) this year as well as in nine of eighteen cases (i.e., three legume species × six years) during the previous six years. This suggests that although protein content is maximized at a greater N rate than is yield, applying more N than recommended inconsistently increases protein content and may not be economically beneficial.

This study is being continued to determine if the observed trends continue and if long-term benefits such as improvement in soil quality are obtained.