Fine-tuning a nitrogen budget system for sugarbeetS producEd UNDER SPRINKLER AND FLOOD IRRIGATION
J. Eckhoff1, J. Bergman1, C. Flynn1, and K. Rasmussen2
Previous crops were durum in 2003, potatoes in 2002, and safflower in 2001. Residual soil N to 4 feet was 28 lb/ac. Residual soil P to 6 inches was 27 ppm and residual soil K to 6 inches was 483 ppm. Five rates of liquid 28-0-0 were applied September 17, 2003. A check treatment with no applied N was included.
Table 1. Residual soil N and applied soil N on sugarbeets grown under sprinkler and flood irrigation.
|
Treatment |
Soil N to 4 feet |
Applied N |
Available N |
|
No applied N |
28 |
0 |
28 |
|
Recommended – 50 lb/ac |
28 |
72 |
100 |
|
Recommended – 25 lb/ac |
28 |
97 |
125 |
|
Recommended |
28 |
122 |
150 |
|
Recommended + 25 lb/ac |
28 |
147 |
175 |
|
Recommended + 50 lb/ac |
28 |
172 |
200 |
Plots were planted to stand with the variety AC927 on Apr 22 with a commercial six-row planter. Ro-Neet 6E (3.5 lb AI/ac) and Counter (1 lb AI/ac) were applied in 7” bands at planting. Betamix (0.75 pt/ac) was applied on June 2. Headline (9.2 oz/ac) was applied by ground rig on July 20. Sprinkler plots were irrigated on Apr 29, May 4, May 22, Jun 29, Jul 15, Jul 21, Jul 28, Aug 5, Aug 12, Aug 23, and Sep 7. Flood irrigated plots were irrigated on Jun 22, Jul 7, Aug 4, Aug 17, and Aug 30. Precipitation for April 1 – September 30 in 2004 was 7.62 inches. Average precipitation for April - September period (56-year average) is 10.72 inches. Plots were harvested on Oct 1.
Table 2. Stand, yield, and quality of sugarbeets grown under flood and sprinkler irrigation with six rates of available N.
|
N to 4 ft and applied N, lb/ac |
Irrigation |
Harvest Stand, plants/ac |
% sucrose |
Root Yield T/acre |
Sucrose Yield, Lb/acre |
Na ppm |
K ppm |
Amino-N ppm |
% extrac-tion |
Extract-able Sucrose, Lb/acre |
|
28 |
flood |
37990 |
19.87 |
26.6 |
10910 |
159 |
1497 |
97 |
96.1 |
10460 |
|
100 |
flood |
37630 |
19.94 |
28.1 |
11210 |
175 |
1575 |
110 |
95.8 |
10740 |
|
125 |
flood |
40050 |
20.27 |
28.4 |
11530 |
169 |
1507 |
103 |
96.1 |
11080 |
|
150 |
flood |
38720 |
20.09 |
27.6 |
11110 |
186 |
1479 |
104 |
96.0 |
10670 |
|
175 |
flood |
39080 |
19.64 |
28.6 |
11210 |
218 |
1515 |
119 |
95.7 |
10730 |
|
200 |
flood |
39930 |
19.43 |
30.5 |
11710 |
240 |
1664 |
130 |
95.1 |
11130 |
|
LSD0.05 |
|
NS |
0.54 |
2.2 |
NS |
39 |
96 |
NS |
0.4 |
NS |
|
28 |
sprinkler |
40540 |
20.01 |
28.1 |
11230 |
174 |
1512 |
118 |
95.9 |
10760 |
|
100 |
sprinkler |
41020 |
19.61 |
30.9 |
12090 |
225 |
1741 |
160 |
94.9 |
11480 |
|
125 |
sprinkler |
41990 |
19.26 |
30.3 |
11680 |
223 |
1688 |
185 |
94.7 |
11060 |
|
150 |
sprinkler |
41500 |
19.29 |
30.4 |
11740 |
208 |
1599 |
168 |
95.1 |
11160 |
|
175 |
sprinkler |
38720 |
19.38 |
29.4 |
11390 |
218 |
1635 |
165 |
95.1 |
10830 |
|
200 |
sprinkler |
42110 |
19.32 |
29.8 |
11520 |
216 |
1575 |
147 |
95.3 |
10970 |
|
LSD0.05 |
|
NS |
0.53 |
NS |
NS |
NS |
155 |
47 |
0.7 |
NS |
Greatest root yield and sucrose yield under flood irrigation were achieved with 200 lb of available N. This treatment had the highest amount of applied N (172 lb/ac). Greatest root yield and sucrose yield under sprinkler irrigation were achieved with 100 lb of available N. This was the lowest amount of applied N (72 lb/ac). Sugarbeets under sprinkler irrigation had higher average impurity contents than sugarbeets under flood irrigation, with greater loss to molasses and lower percent extraction. These data indicate that sprinkler irrigated sugarbeets need less applied N than flood irrigation sugarbeets.
1 Montana State University Eastern Agricultural Research Center, Sidney, MT
2 Sidney Sugars, Incorporated, Sidney, MT
![]() |